Firstly, take the time, if you will, to read an article by Bruce Sterling, this one.
And then read this, a brief outline of a study done by Associate Professor John Asafu-Adjaye.
Now, to be fair, I should really read Growth Fetish by Clive Hamilton before I can form a balanced opinion here.
But a possible conclusion to draw from the first two, though probably contrary to the third, is that a green future is not an ideal belonging only to those of the far reachest of green left. It would seem that theres is empirical evidence linking improved economic growth and the greening of an environment, which may be summed up by Asafu-Adjaye when he says
“In many cases people start to care about the environment because they can afford to,”
Note, though, the qualifer 'in many cases'. It certainly isn't a universal occurence, but it is a possibility. Another criticism is that the study only focused on carbon dioxide emissions as a measure of environmental quality.
But still.
Take for example
Some radical types seem to be anti-capitalist, or anti-corporate, to the extreme point where it becomes anti-wealth. Just as some ultra-conservative types seem to conflate any environmental protection with poverty and economic decline. I think this is a worrying trend. I consider myself of a moderate center-left, middle of the road persuasion, a bit like Paul Keating perhaps, or currently Barack Obama. Keating is/was certainly my favourite politician- watch his Lateline interview if you haven't! And as he points out in the interview, he initiated several drastic economic changes. Changes which are still feeding our prosperity today.
My point is, before there is anything to share around to those who need it, we first need to create that wealth. This is a point that only the most extreme seem unable to grasp, and something that most of us can agree on, surely. It's the management of that wealth, and how to generate it, that is a point worthy of debate.
But like I said, I should read Growth Fetish first.
1 comment:
Good write-up.
I'm reading Growth Fetish at the moment (well, I haven't read it for a few months, but it's one of about eight books I have a bookmark in) and I can highly recommend it. Hamilton is very eloquent and argues his point clearly and cleverly, and he certainly doesn't pull any punches.
Post a Comment